PMQs: Starmer faces MPs after backlash over his defence investment plan – UK politics live
Key events15m agoBurnham 'a true patriot' who will keep the country safe, says defence secretary Dan Jarvis26m agoStarmer faces Badenoch at PMQs28m agoCMA launches review of early years education and. . .
Key events15m agoBurnham 'a true patriot' who will keep the country safe, says defence secretary Dan Jarvis26m agoStarmer faces Badenoch at PMQs28m agoCMA launches review of early years education and childcare services in England37m agoSwinney says Burnham wrong to say people in Dundee feel as distant from Holyrood as they do from Westminster2h agoHousebuilding in Scotland at lowest level for almost a decade, figures show3h agoAnnouncing spending plan while deferring saying where all money coming from 'not unusual', says minister3h agoMinisters ‘furious’ over cuts to road projects to fund defence plan3h agoStarmer to take penultimate PMQs as he faces backlash over ‘poisoned chalice’ defence investment planBadenochsays this settlement is not fair for our troops. John Healey said, when he resigned, that he was having to take decisions that would make the country less safe. How can the PM stand there and say this is enough?Starmersays this is the biggest upgrade to defence capacity since the 1980s. He quotes the defence chiefs welcoming it, and the Nato secretary general too. He says the Tories cut defence spending. He has boosted defence spending, he says. The Tories missed recruitment targets. Labourhas put defence pay up, he says. Kemi Badenochsays she agrees with Starmer about Venezuela – and the Lib Dems. She says the armed forces said they needed £28bn for defence. Why is Starmer only giving them half of that?Starmersays the government is making a record investment in defence. It is what is needed to keep the country safe. Al Pinkerton(Lib Dem) says a site chosen for a hospital relocation in his Surrey Heath constituency is unsuitable. Starmersays this hospital is in the front of the queue for new projects. But Pinkerton has demanded a new hospital while objecting to the site. He says Pinkerton complained the new site would remove a golf course. He jokes that demanding a hospital but standing up for golf courses is very Lib Dem. Keir Starmerstarts by saying MPs are thinking of the people of Venezuela. He says Sunday marks the 70th anniversary of the NHS. He says waiting times are falling, and he welcomes the deal with resident doctors on pay. Burnham 'a true patriot' who will keep the country safe, says defence secretary Dan JarvisDan SabbaghDan Sabbagh is the Guardian’s defence and security editor. Andy Burnham is a “true patriot” who will provide the money needed to maintain Britain’s security when he becomes prime minister, the new defence secretary,Dan Jarvis, said on a visit to a factory in Cambridge today. Speaking a day after publication of the defence investment plan, Jarvis insisted the UK would meet a Nato commitment to lift defence spending to 3. 5% of GDP - and that the prime minister-in-waiting would help. He said:double quotation markI’ve known Andy Burnham for more than 15 years, he is a true patriot, and I absolutely believe that he will make sure that we have the resources that we need to field the kind of capabilities that are required given the nature of the world that we’re operating in. The minister added the UK had made “an ironcast” commitment to Nato allies to spend 3. 5% of GDP on defence, and that there needs to be “a trajectory to it” in future years. The spending plan leaves defence at 2. 7% of GDP in 2030. He said:double quotation markI know what we need to do to keep Britain safe, and I’m absolutely confident that Andy Burnham, as the next prime minister, knows that as well, and we’ll make sure in the context of the next spending review that we’ve got the resources we need to keep the country safe. The spending plan, agreed after months of cabinet wrangling, leaves the UK over £25bn a year in real terms short of the final target. Concern about the difference led to the resignation of Jarvis’s predecessor John Healey earlier this month. Dan Jarvis (centre) stands with Britain's chief of the defence staff Air Chief Marshal Sir Richard Knighton (left) and founder and CEO Steven Barrett (R) as he cuts the ceremonial opening ribbon during a visit to Cambridge Aerospace today. Photograph: Leon Neal/Getty ImagesStarmer faces Badenoch at PMQsPMQs is starting soon. Here is the list of MPs down to ask a question. PMQsPhotograph: HoCCMA launches review of early years education and childcare services in EnglandSally WealeSally Weale is a Guardian education correspondent. TheCompetition and Markets Authority(CMA) has launcheda review of early years educationand childcare services in England, amid concerns about the hidden costs parents face, pressures on nurseries and the growing presence of private equity providers in the market. It follows a request by education secretary Bridget Phillipson who expressed her concerns in anarticle in the Guardian in Maythat too many parents are still not feeling the benefits of the government’s £9. 5bn investment in funded childcare. She wrote:double quotation markThe vast majority of nurseries and childminders are doing a brilliant job – but we have to ask hard questions every time we hear stories of families hit with hidden charges, restricted hours or excessive deposits that bear no relation to what parents are actually paying. Phillipson also raised concerns about a doubling in the number of nurseries backed by private equity and investment firms. For every £5 spent at an investment-backed nursery in England, she said more than £1 ends up as profit – double what other private nurseries make and seven times more than non-profits. Sarah Cardell, CMA chief executive, said:double quotation markWe know how important it is to find affordable providers close to home that parents can trust. But too many families are struggling to find the right place at an affordable price, with providers also under real pressure. We’re going to take a close look at where change may be needed as part of our commitment to support economic growth and household prosperity, so the system works well for families and providers alike. Neil Leitch, chief executive of the Early Years Alliance, which represents 14,000 childcare providers, said:double quotation markFor all the positive rhetoric on the importance of the early years, the fact is that sustained underfunding – across successive governments – has left far too many settings with no choice but to raise fees and prices or risk permanent closure, while many families still face a postcode lottery when it comes to finding early years places. There are more than 53,000 childcare providers in England, providing an estimated 1. 6bn places for children aged 0-4 in a sector with an estimated annual value of £14bn to the economy. The CMA findings will inform a wider government review of childcare provision. For more on private equity, this Guardian explainer launched earlier this week on the impact private equity has had in the veterinary medicine sector is excellent. Swinney says Burnham wrong to say people in Dundee feel as distant from Holyrood as they do from WestminsterJohn Swinneyhas rejected Andy Burnham’s claim that parts of Scotland feel as distant from Holyrood as they do from Westminster, the Press Association reports. In his speech in Manchester on Monday,Burnham, who is set to become PM later this month, said:double quotation mark[The work of No 10. North] will be about offering new opportunities to extend devolution in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland by taking power deeper down. The people of Dundee and Bangor feel just as distant from Holyrood and the Senedd as they do from Westminster. Asked about this comment,Swinneytold the Press Association:double quotation markI don’t agree with them that areas feel distant from Holyrood. The city of Dundee just re-elected SNP members of the Scottish parliament and the Labour party got terrible results in the city. I don’t really think Andy Burnham is in a strong position to lecture me about all of these questions. I think rather than offering us these polemics, if Andy Burnham is going to become the prime minister, he should have a substantive discussion with the Scottish government and me about how we empower and strengthen the powers of the Scottish parliament …He’s spent years telling us that Whitehall doesn’t work, that Westminster is broken, and that means he’s got to devolve more powers to the Scottish parliament, and in that respect, I’ll be a willing partner in making sure that’s the case. Swinney also said he did not want to see elected mayors inScotland. double quotation markWhat I agree with is having empowered and strong local authorities, as we have in Scotland. I want to make sure they’ve got more power and more scope to increase economic performance in individual localities. John Swinney (left) posing for a selfie with swimmer Duncan Scott after his journey up the River Clyde in Glasgow for the official launch of the Scotland leg of the King's Baton Relay ahead of the Commonwealth Games. Photograph: Jane Barlow/PAAndy Burnham has not yet become PM, but already the rightwing papers are exploring how best to present him negatively in the eyes of their readers. Yesterday the Daily Mail splashed ona storysaying Burnham wants “to run Britain part-time from Manchester”. The 10-word intro managed to simultaneously imply that Burnham would be working from home a bit, not fully committed to the job, and anti-London. Today the Telegraph has got an even more ingenious line of attack. It is running a headline saying: “Burnham could ‘turbocharge North-South house price divide’. ” Thestorysays house prices are growing at 3. 9% in the north and north-west, compared to just 0. 1% in the south-east, and it quotes someone from a property search company saying: “A huge injection of government spending into the north could create a Burnham bounce that accelerates northern price growth further. ” While this sounds like a grave injustice to homeowners in the south (where Telegraph readers live), they might have been reassured if the article had included figures showing thathouse prices on average are far higher in the south than in the north. Burnham’s political project is all about reducing that divide, not turbocharging it. Andy Burnham’s team is “properly furious” about the £5bn black hole in the funding for the defence investment plan, according toSam Coatesfrom Sky News. Onhis podcastthis morning, Coatessaid:double quotation markI am old enough to remember when Rachel Reeves and Keir Starmer came into government complaining from every hilltop that the Tories did just similar by cutting budgets and failing to fully fund them. It’s no wonder that Team Burnham are, for the first time in this transition I think, properly furious, right? They’ve really avoided briefing until now, but it was made clear to me yesterday they are cross about this because they didn’t know and it’s a big headache. To be fair, compared to some of the other budget and public policy problems facing a Burnham administration, having to find £5bn over four years (it’sa cumulative figure, not an annual figure) may not be welcome but it’s hardly the biggest challenge they will be facing. Housebuilding in Scotland at lowest level for almost a decade, figures showRobyn VinterRobyn Vinter is a Guardian reporter coveringScotland. Housebuilding in Scotland is down to its lowest level in nearly a decade,official figures show. Apart from 2020-21, when Covid impacted housebuilding, completions were the lowest since 2016-17, Scottish government statistics show. A total of 17,268 new homes were built, and 14,955 homes were started in Scotland in 2025-26, a 10% and 4% drop respectively on the previous year. Critics have said at the current rate of progress, the Scottish government’s target to deliver 110,000 affordable homes by 2032 will be missed by a significant margin. ScottishLabourhousing spokespersonMark Griffinsaid:double quotation markScotland’s housing emergency is causing misery for families all over the country and this fall in housebuilding will fan the flames of the crisis. The Lib Dem MSPMorven-May MacCallumsaid the “chopping and changing of housing policy must end”. She added:double quotation markToo many Scots have nowhere to live or are paying through the nose. Housebuilding is going in the wrong direction and this needs to change. Announcing spending plan while deferring saying where all money coming from 'not unusual', says ministerLuke Pollard, a defence minister, has been giving interviews this morning. Speaking to Times Radio, he defended the government’s decision to defer explaining how around one third of the £15bn defence investment plan (Dip) will be funded until the budget in the autumn. He claimed that leaving a hole in spending plans like this was “not unusual”. He said:double quotation markWe’ve announced a £15bn increase in defence spending, which is a huge boost for our readiness and helps us buy the kit and equipment that we need. Of the £15 billion extra spending power that we now have, the Treasury set out how £10bn or so of that will be spent … £4. 7bn will be set out at the autumn budget. And that’s not unusual for governments to do. When Rachel Reeves announceda U-turn on the winter fuel payments cutlast summer, costing £1. 25bn, she also put off explaining how it would be funded until the budget later in the year. In his interviews Pollard also declined to comment on reports thatAndy Burnhamand his team were not told about the £5bn black hole in the plans until the figures were published yesterday. Pollard told the Today programme that he only saw details of how the £15bn would be raised yesterday, and that he was “not involved” in the talks with the Burnham operation. Burnham is expected to become PM in just under three weeks. Ministers ‘furious’ over cuts to road projects to fund defence planHere isJessica Elgot’s story about the backlash over the proposed road scheme cuts that will part-fund the defence investment plan. Starmer to take penultimate PMQs as he faces backlash over ‘poisoned chalice’ defence investment planGood morning. YesterdayKeir Starmerpublished the defence investment plan (Dip), which was probably the last substantial announcement of his premiership. Today he is facing what will probably be his second last PMQs (he is expected to be at the Nato summit next Wednesday, and he’ll have his swansong on 15 July), and the session is likely to be dominated by complaints about the Dip. Broadly, there are three distinct criticisms. 1) ‘It doesn’t raise defence spending by anything like enough. ’This is what military chiefs (in private) and retired military leaders (on TV) have been saying for ages. Yesterday theInstitute for Fiscal Studiesin effect agreed. In a briefing, it said the rise in defence spending under Labour had been “substantial”. But the problem is that last year,under pressure from Donald Trump, Keir Starmer and other Nato leaders committedto raising defence spending to 3. 5% of GDP by 2035and,as the IFS explains, despite the increase announced yesterday, there is as yet no credible path to get there. 2) ‘It is not even properly funded. ’AsKiran StaceyandDan Sabbaghexplain in the Guardian’s splash story, the Dip amounts to a £15bn spending increase – but there is as yet no explanation as to where the money will come from to fund almost £5bn of this. That is a problem forAndy Burnham, who was not briefed on the black hole ahead of the publication of the Dip yesterday, and for his chancellor. Last nightLiam Fox, the former Tory defence secretary, said that Starmer was leaving a “poisoned chalice” for his successor. 3) ‘And the bits that are funded are in part funded by cuts that are not popular. ’Some of the Dip is being funded by the cancellation of road projects, and this has angered Labour MPs whose constituencies are affected. Hamish Falconeris a Foreign Office minister, and normally ministers don’t criticise government decisions in public. But he is also MP for Lincoln and last night he posteda messageon social media saying he was “disappointed” by the threat to the A46 Newark bypass widening scheme. In the CommonsJonathan Davies, MP for Mid Derbyshire, said shelving the A38 Derby Junctions scheme would be “a brake on economic growth”. And last nightClaire Ward, the Labour mayor for the East Midlands, complained her region was disproportionately affected. She told the the Cathy Newman Show on Sky:double quotation markWhat I’m complaining about today is that the East Midlands would appear to be the only region that has been told it is sacrificing its road investments programme in order to be able to contribute to the Dip. Here is the agenda for the day. 9. 30am:MPs hold a debate in Westminster Hall on the case for banning MPs from having second jobs. Morning:Dan Jarvis, the defence secretary, is on a visit in Cambridgeshire. Noon:Keir Starmer facesKemi Badenochat PMQs. 2. 15pm:Police chiefs give evidence to the joint committee on human rights on the policing of protests. If you want to contact me, please post a message below the line when comments are open (between 10am and 3pm), or message me on social media. I can’t read all the messages BTL, but if you put “Andrew” in a message aimed at me, I am more likely to see it because I search for posts containing that word. If you want to flag something up urgently, it is best to use social media. You can reach me on Bluesky at @andrewsparrowgdn. bsky. social. The Guardian hasgiven up posting from its official accounts on X, but individual Guardian journalists are there, I still have my account, and if you message me there at @AndrewSparrow, I will see it and respond if necessary. I find it very helpful when readers point out mistakes, even minor typos. No error is too small to correct. And I find your questions very interesting too. I can’t promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either BTL or sometimes in the blog.